Lake Ontario Lakewide Management Plan
Bienniel Report Highlights April 2002
| The following is a summary of the findings of
the Lake Ontario Lakewide Management Plan Report 2002. If you are
interested in receiving a copy of the complete report, please contact
Marlene O'Brien or Mike Basile at the addresses listed at the end
of this article. |
What is the Lake Ontario LaMP?
The Lake Ontario Lakewide Management Plan (LaMP) is a binational framework
for coordinating environmental efforts on Lake Ontario, as called for
under the U.S. - Canada Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement. The main
purpose of the LaMP is to reduce the amount of contaminants entering the
lake and address causes of lakewide problems. The LaMP is led by the "Four
Parties": Environment Canada, United States Environmental Protection Agency,
Ontario Ministry of the Environment and New York State Department of Environmental
Conservation.
The Lake Ontario LaMP Stage 1 Report published in 1998 identified four
lakewide problems, known as beneficial use impairments:
- Restrictions on fish and wildlife consumption
- Bird or animal deformities or reproductive problems
- Degradation of wildlife populations
- Loss of fish and wildlife habitat
The LaMP Stage 1 Report determined that the first three impairments are
caused by elevated levels of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), DDT, mirex,
dioxins/furans and mercury in the ecosystem. These chemicals are all designated
as critical pollutants by the LaMP and are the focus of source trackdown
and pollution prevention activities.
The impairment, loss of fish and wildlife habitat, is caused by a combination
of factors such as exotic species, land use changes and lake level controls.
The restoration of these beneficial uses will require coordinated binational
actions.

Map Credit: Environment Canada
Lake Ontario LaMP 2002 Report
The Lake Ontario LaMP 2002 Report provides a summary of actions taken
and progress made by the LaMP since the Stage 1 Report was released. This
report describes the development and adoption of ecosystem indicators
for monitoring progress in restoration, provides an assessment of the
status of beneficial use impairments, and updates information on levels
of critical pollutants. It also summarizes new agency efforts to identify
and control sources of critical pollutants impacting the lake.
What are the Goals of the LaMP?
The ecosystem objectives for Lake Ontario are:
- Diverse, healthy aquatic communities
- Diverse, healthy wildlife communities
- Protection of human health
- Sufficient quality habitat
- Responsible stewardship
How Does the LaMP Measure Progress?
Measurement tools called ecosystem indicators are used to track the progress
in restoring the Lake Ontario ecosystem. Eleven specific ecosystem indicators
have been adopted to represent overall ecosystem health. These indicators
provide an accurate picture of ecosystem health across the food web and
are already part of ongoing long-term U.S. and Canadian monitoring programs.
The status of these indicators will be highlighted in future reports.
Water quality is monitored to ensure that nutrient levels
are sufficient to support aquatic life and are not causing unsightly algal
blooms. Photo Credit: Environment Canada.
It is necessary to monitor cross sections of the food chain
to understand the impacts of chemical, physical and biological changes
occurring in the lake. Even low concentrations of pollutants in water
can bioaccumulate through the food web to reach levels of concern in fish
consumed by humans and wildlife. Source: The Great Lakes Atlas - An Environmental
Atlas & Resource Book, 3rd Edition.
Three categories of ecosystem indicators have been selected for Lake
Ontario:
Critical pollutant indicators that measure concentrations of critical
pollutants in water, young-of-the-year fish, herring gull eggs and lake
trout for comparison against existing guidelines.
Lower foodweb indicators that track the status of nutrients, phytoplankton,
zooplankton, and prey fish. These indicators reflect the ability of the
ecosystem to support higher level organisms such as lake trout and waterbirds.
Upper foodweb indicators that monitor the health of herring gulls,
lake trout, bald eagles, mink and otter populations. These top predators
are dependent on quality habitat and sufficient populations of prey, free
of problematic contaminant levels.

The otter is an animal that consumes fish and other aquatic
animals. It has been chosen as a critical indicator species for the Lake
Ontario ecosystem. Photo Credit: Dennis Money
Results Show Continued Improvements
Recent findings presented in the Lake Ontario LaMP 2002 Report indicate
that the management of critical pollutants has been effective in reducing
their presence in the ecosystem, and that fish and wildlife have responded
positively to this improvement.
Overall, fish tissue has shown a significant reduction in critical pollutant
levels since the 1970s. Levels of critical pollutants in Lake Ontario
coho salmon have been decreasing steadily. Total PCB concentrations have
gone down by 2/3 and the concentration of mirex has decreased by 1/2.
It is hoped that these trends will continue as source trackdown and remedial
actions further reduce the amount of critical pollutants entering the
Lake Ontario ecosystem.

Long term monitoring of coho salmon from Lake Ontario illustrate
a steady reduction in PCB levels over time.
Populations of fish-eating waterbirds in Lake Ontario have recovered
and are reproducing normally. Caspian terns, common terns, gulls and cormorants
have all benefitted from the reduction in pollutants. Several key indicator
species such as the bald eagle, lake trout, river otter and mink are also
making a comeback in the Lake Ontario ecosystem.

Caspian tern numbers on Lake Ontario are increasing. Photo
Credit: Don Simonelli
Although bald eagles have been successfully nesting in the Lake Ontario
basin since the 1980s, they are finally nesting on the shores of Lake
Ontario after a forty-year absence. Two shoreline nests have been established.
The success of these eagle nests suggests that contaminants are no longer
a significant barrier to the recovery of bald eagles on the Lake Ontario
shoreline.
The Return of Lake Trout
Early 1900s - Native lake trout populations eliminated due to overfishing,
habitat loss and sea lamprey impacts.
1960s - Stocking of lake trout begins to restore top-level predator
fish to the food web with a goal of reestablishing naturally reproducing
populations.
1990s - First signs of naturally reproduced lake trout.
2000s - Natural reproduction is expected to increase as more naturally
spawned fish reach reproductive age.

Photo Credit: Fisheries and Oceans Canada
|
Reducing Critical Pollutants
The Four Parties have developed and agreed to a cooperative binational
approach for reducing critical pollutants to the lake. This approach encompasses
the reduction of critical pollutants through regulatory programs and partnerships
with local government, industries and individuals. Using this approach,
sources of critical pollutants are identified through trackdown activities,
as well as assessed and addressed using regulatory or voluntary actions.
Environment Canada and the Ontario Ministry of the Environment are working
together to identify the sources of PCBs and other critical pollutants
in large streams and rivers that flow into Lake Ontario. Concentrations
of PCBs in water, sediment and fish are measured at various locations
along rivers or streams entering Lake Ontario in order to determine where
the critical pollutants are coming from and how to address them. A pilot
source trackdown project has begun on three priority watersheds and data
are currently being analyzed. The information gained from these activities
will help focus remediation and pollution prevention efforts that will
ultimately reduce the amount of critical pollutants entering the lake.
The United States Environmental Protection Agency and the New York State
Department of Environmental Conservation are working together to locate
and address sources of critical pollutants. Water, sediment and fish are
collected at strategic locations to identify where and how critical pollutants
are entering streams and rivers. Trackdown sampling results have also
helped develop a good picture of the location and extent of critical pollutant
sources and problems in the watersheds of the U.S. portion of the basin.
These efforts have helped sewage treatment plants qualify for New York
State funding to upgrade their treatment systems, thereby reducing critical
pollutant inputs to the lake. The agencies will continue to support critical
pollutant trackdown activities as well as to promote pesticide and household
hazardous waste collections.

Trackdown sampling involves sampling water in local sewer
systems for contaminants such as PCBs. Photo Credit: USEPA
Restoring beneficial uses in Lake Ontario will also depend on the success
of other Great Lakes programs, such as the Great Lakes Binational Toxics
Strategy. The Canada-Ontario Agreement and the U.S. Great Lakes Toxics
Strategy also include commitments that address persistent toxic substances
in Lake Ontario. It is only through coordinated and focused initiatives
such as these that the effects of critical pollutants can be effectively
reduced and beneficial uses can be restored.
Sources & Loadings Update
The Lake Ontario LaMP 2002 Report provides estimates of the amount
of each of the 6 critical pollutants that enter and exit the Lake
Ontario ecosystem. These estimates will be used to help guide future
trackdown and control activities. As Lake Ontario is the last in
the chain of the Great Lakes, most of the critical pollutant loadings
come from outside the basin.
|
Challenges Ahead
Although progress to date has been significant, further reductions of
critical pollutant loadings are needed in order to meet the LaMP ecosystem
objectives.
The LaMP recently completed an assessment of bottom-dwelling organisms
(benthos) and microscopic aquatic plants (phytoplankton). This assessment
concluded that benthos and nearshore phytoplankton populations are degraded
due to zebra mussel-related impacts. The LaMP will promote the prevention
of future introductions of exotic species by raising awareness of the
problem and the need to take action.

Zebra mussels are causing serious lakewide problems in
the Lake Ontario ecosystem. Photo Credit: Centre for Great Lakes & Aquatic
Sciences
Efforts to preserve and restore fish and wildlife habitat have shown
mixed results. Programs to control runoff and erosion, protect stream
banks and improve agricultural tillage practices have been successful,
where they have been implemented. However, urban and agricultural development,
land use practices and lake-level controls still threaten habitat. Opportunities
to protect and restore important habitats are being explored by the LaMP
in addition to continuing support of ongoing habitat protection efforts.

More efforts to create, preserve and restore fish and wildlife
habitat are needed in the Lake Ontario basin. Photo Credit: Bay Area Restoration
Council.
Public Involvement
Public involvement is an important component of the LaMP. Annual public
meetings, newsletters, reports, presentations, displays and website updates
increase public understanding and awareness of the LaMP and its goals.
For more information on how to get involved, see the contact details provided
at the end of this brochure.

Giving presentations about the Lake Ontario LaMP is just
one of the important aspects of public involvement. Photo Credit: Ontario
Ministry of the Environment
Next Steps
Future efforts will continue to focus on the restoration of impaired
beneficial uses. Contaminant trackdown activities will continue to provide
a better understanding of critical pollutant sources. The information
gained from these activities will help focus remediation and pollution
prevention efforts that ultimately will reduce the amount of critical
pollutants in the lake.
Coordination of binational monitoring efforts, particularly those related
to the LaMP's ecosystem indicators, will be a special area of emphasis.
The status of the eleven ecosystem indicators will be highlighted in upcoming
reports and presentations.
The LaMP will work to strengthen partnerships, keep stakeholders informed
and encourage greater public involvement and participation in the restoration
of the Lake Ontario ecosystem.
Lake Ontario LaMP 2002
The Lake Ontario LaMP 2002 Report provides a summary of actions taken
and progress made by the LaMP. Highlights of the Report include:
- The LaMP has adopted ecosystem indicators to track progress
- Fish and wildlife populations have improved
- Populations of benthos and phytoplankton are degraded due to zebra
mussels
- Levels of critical pollutants in fish and wildlife continue to decline
- Sources of critical pollutants in the Lake Ontario basin are being
addressed
In addition, the report provides an update of public involvement activities
and outlines next steps.

For More Information
To obtain a copy of the report, or for other information, contact:
Marlene O'Brien
Environment Canada
867 Lakeshore Road
Burlington, Ontario
L7R 4A6
Phone: (905) 336-4552
Fax: (905) 336-6272
Email: marlene.obrien@ec.gc.ca
Mike Basile
United States Environmental Protection Agency
Public Information Office
345 Third Street, Suite 530
Niagara Falls, NY 14303
Phone: (716) 285-8842
Fax: (716) 285-8788
Email: NFPIO@sysr.com
|